ERF for heat exposure and mortality

From Opasnet
Jump to navigation Jump to search



TODO: {{#todo:There is an overlap between this page and ERF of ambient temperature on mortality. These should be merged. I prefer the latter name.|Virpi Kollanus, Teemu Rintala|Intarese}}


Scope

Exposure-response relationship for short-term ambient heat exposure and mortality.

Dimensions and boundaries relevant for the variable

  • Cause of death
  • Country/other geographic area (differences in heat exposure/effects due to climate, physiological, cultural or behavioral factors)
  • Age of exposed population

Definition

Data

PHEWE-project [1]

Meta-analytical percent changes in mortality by age-group with 1oC increase in maximum apparent temperature above the city-specific threshold temperature in European cities


Mediterranean cities North-continental cities
Cause of death Age (years) % change 95% Cl % change 95% Cl
All natural causes All 3.12 0.60, 5.73 1.84 0.06, 3.64
15-64 0.92 -1.29, 3.13 1.31 -0.94, 3.72
65-74 2.13 -0.42, 4.74 1.65 -0.51, 3.89
75+ 4.22 1.33, 7.20 2.07 0.24, 3.89
Cardiovascular All 3.70 0.36, 7.04 2.44 -0.09, 5.32
15-64 0.57 -2.47, 3.83 1.04 -2.20, 4.92
65-74 1.92 -1.49, 5.35 1.50 -1.12, 4.62
75+ 4.66 1.13, 8.18 2.55 -0.24, 5.51
Respiratory All 6.71 2.43, 11.26 6.10 2.46, 11.08
15-64 1.54 -3.68, 7.22 3.02 -1.55, 7.42
65-74 3.37 -1.46, 8.22 3.90 -0.16, 8.92
75+ 8.10 3.24, 13.37 6.62 3.04, 11.42
  • Meta-analytical estimates are based studies in the following cities:
    • Mediterranean cities: Athens, Rome, Barcelona, Valencia, Turin, Milan, Lubljana
    • North-continental cities: Prague, Budapest, Zurich, Paris, Helsinki, Stockholm, London, Dublin
  • Based on climate and mortality data for the period 1990-2000
  • Exposure assessment: daily maximum apparent outdoor air temperature (nearest airport weather station of each city)

Maud's interpretation of PHEWE[2].

ERF of heat on mortality.
Region Cause of death Age % change per 1 degree above threshold
Nothern continental TOTAL 15-64 1.31
Nothern continental TOTAL 65-74 1.65
Nothern continental TOTAL 75+ 2.07
Nothern continental CVD 15-64 1.04
Nothern continental CVD 65-74 1.50
Nothern continental CVD 75+ 2.55
Nothern continental RESP 15-64 3.02
Nothern continental RESP 65-74 3.90
Nothern continental RESP 75+ 6.62
Mediterranean TOTAL 15-64 0.92
Mediterranean TOTAL 65-74 2.13
Mediterranean TOTAL 75+ 4.22
Mediterranean CVD 15-64 0.57
Mediterranean CVD 65-74 1.92
Mediterranean CVD 75+ 4.66
Mediterranean RESP 15-64 1.54
Mediterranean RESP 65-74 3.37
Mediterranean RESP 75+ 8.10


Temperature threshold:

  • standard threshold (29.4 °C)
  • high threshold (32.4 °C)
  • low threshold (25.7 °C)

Dependencies

Unit

1/°C (log(RR) per 1 °C increase in the ambient temperature above the threshold)

Formula

coefficient = ln(ERF of heat on mortality/100 + 1) incremental exposure = heat exposure - heat exposure baseline

Result

See also

References

  1. Baccini M, Biggeri A, Accetta G, Kosatsky T, Katsouyanni K, Analitis A, Ross Anderson H, Bisanti L, D'Ippoliti D, Danova J, Forsberg B, Medina S, Paldy A, Rabczenko D, Schindler C & Michelozzi P. 2008. Heat Effects on Mortality in 15 European Cities. Epidemiology, 15: 711-719.
  2. Baccini et al 2008 Epidemiology, vol 19, number 5, pp. 711-719