Indoor environment quality (IEQ) factors: Difference between revisions
Line 105: | Line 105: | ||
Soroush Majlesi and Adnan Ahmad ''''' Packer et al. (1994) <ref>*Packer et al. Damp housing and adult health: results from a lifestyle study in Worcester, England.Journal of epidemiology and community health 1994;48(6):555–559</ref> | Soroush Majlesi and Adnan Ahmad ''''' Packer et al. (1994) <ref>*Packer et al. Damp housing and adult health: results from a lifestyle study in Worcester, England.Journal of epidemiology and community health 1994;48(6):555–559</ref> | ||
Jukka Hirvonen and Sami Rissanen ''''' Blackman et al. (2001) <ref>*Blackman T, Harvey J, Lawrence M & Simon A. (2001). Neighbourhood renewal and health: evidence from a local case study. Health & Place 7(2001), 93-103.</ref> | |||
'''Precision and Plausability of Hopton and Hunt (1996)''' | '''Precision and Plausability of Hopton and Hunt (1996)''' |
Revision as of 07:53, 1 February 2013
Moderator:Marjo (see all) |
This page is a stub. You may improve it into a full page. |
Upload data
|
Question
What established or possible indoor environment quality (IEQ) factors exist? What kind of dose-responses have been defined for them?
Answer
Obs | Exposure metric | Response | Response metric | Exposure route | Exposure unit | ERF parameter | ERF | Significance | Description/Reference |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | Visible dampness and/or mold or mold odor | Respiratory health effect | Respiratory symptoms and diseases | Inhalation | yes/no | OR | several, see Note 1 | Note 1 | |
2 | Dampness and/or mold | Depression | Inhalation, Other? | Note 2 | |||||
3 | Dampness and/or mold | Mental health problems | Inhalation, Other? | Note 2 | |||||
4 | Dampness and/or mold | Self-assessed health poorer | Inhalation, Other? | Note 2 | |||||
5 | Dampness and/or mold | Mental health problems | Inhalation | yes/no | OR | 1,76 (1,17-2,66) | Hopton and Hunt (1996) | ||
6 | Chronic illness | Mental health problems | no | yes/no | OR | 1,99 (1,32-3,02) | Hopton and Hunt (1996) | ||
7 | Living with children under 16 y | Mental health problems | no | yes/no | OR | 1,75 (1,15-2,68) | Hopton and Hunt (1996) | ||
8 | Living in a low income household | Mental health problems | no | yes/no | OR | 1,61 (1,06-2,44) | Hopton and Hunt (1996) | ||
9 | Respondent unemployed | Mental health problems | no | yes/no | OR | 1,55 (0,99-2,42) | Hopton and Hunt (1996) | ||
10 | Wood smoke | Respiratory health effect | Respiratory symptoms and infections | Inhalation | Note 3, Note 4 | ||||
11 | Wood smoke | Irritation of eyes and mucosa | |||||||
12 | Wood smoke | Respiratory health effect | Asthma aggravating | Inhalation | |||||
13 | Wood smoke | Odour problems | Inhalation | ||||||
14 | Wood smoke | Comfort of housing | Decreased comfort of housing | ||||||
15 | Wood smoke | Chronic infections | Inhalation | ||||||
16 | Wood smoke | Cancer | Inhalation | ||||||
17 | Tobacco smoke | Respiratory health effect | Respiratory symptoms and infections | Inhalation | |||||
18 | Tobacco smoke | Irritation of eyes and mucosa | |||||||
19 | Tobacco smoke | Respiratory health effect | Asthma aggravating | ||||||
20 | Tobacco smoke | Odour problems | Inhalation | ||||||
21 | Tobacco smoke | Comfort of housing | Decreased comfort of housing | ||||||
22 | Tobacco smoke | Chronic infections | Inhalation | ||||||
23 | Tobacco smoke | Cancer | |||||||
24 | VOCs | irritation symptoms etc. | |||||||
25 | CO2 | headache, tiredness etc. | |||||||
26 | CO | headache, tiredness etc. | |||||||
27 | Insufficient air exchange | Headache | |||||||
28 | Insufficient air exchange | Tiredness | |||||||
29 | Insufficient air exchange | Decreased ability to concentrate | |||||||
30 | Insufficient air exchange | Feeling of fug | |||||||
31 | Thermal conditions; heat | Tiredness | |||||||
32 | Thermal conditions; heat | Decreased ability to concentrate | |||||||
33 | Thermal conditions; heat | Increased respiratory symptoms | |||||||
34 | Thermal conditions; heat | Feeling of dryness | |||||||
35 | Thermal conditions; heat | Comfort of housing | Decreased comfort of housing | ||||||
36 | Thermal comfort (draught or cold) | Mental health problems | Note 2 | ||||||
37 | Thermal comfort (heat or cold) | Depression | Note 2 | ||||||
38 | Thermal comfort (heat or cold; general perception of thermal problems) | Self-assessed health poorer | Note 2 | ||||||
39 | Thermal conditions (cold) | Feeling of draught | |||||||
40 | Thermal conditions (cold) | Comfort of housing | Decreased comfort of housing | ||||||
41 | Noise | Hearing injury | |||||||
42 | Noise | Sleep disturbance | |||||||
43 | Noise | Stress | |||||||
44 | Noise | Comfort of housing | Decreased comfort of housing | ||||||
45 | Proximity to traffic | Mortality(?) | |||||||
46 | Radon | Lung cancer | Note 5 | ||||||
47 | Relative humidity | ||||||||
48 | PM | mortality | Note 3 | ||||||
49 | PM | chronic bronchitis | |||||||
50 | PM | lung cancer | |||||||
51 | Reduced space (house/flat) | Depression | Note 2 | ||||||
52 | Reduced space (house/flat) | Mental health problems | Note 2 | ||||||
53 | Reduced space (house/flat) | Self-assessed health poorer | Note 2 | ||||||
54 | Garden | Depression | Note 2 | ||||||
55 | Floor level | Mental health problems | Note 2 | ||||||
56 | Overcrowding | Mental health problems | Note 2 | ||||||
57 | Overcrowding | Self assessed health poorer | Note 2 | ||||||
58 | Sensory IAQ | Various health and well-being parameters | |||||||
59 | Maternal employment | Maltreatment of Children | Other | yes/no | OR | 2.82 (1.59 - 5.00) | Sidebotham et al. 2002 | ||
60 | No. of house moves in previous 5 years | Maltreatment of Children | Other | 2-3 | OR | 1.32 (0.77 - 2.27) | Sidebotham et al. 2002 | ||
61 | No. of house moves in previous 5 years | Maltreatment of Children | Other | 4 or more | OR | 2.81 (1.59 - 4.96) | Sidebotham et al. 2002 | ||
62 | Accomodation | Maltreatment of Children | Other | overcrowed | OR | 2.16 | Sidebotham et al. 2002 | ||
63 | Accomodation | Maltreatment of Children | Other | Council | OR | 7.65 | Sidebotham et al. 2002 | ||
64 | Accomodation | Maltreatment of Children | Other | Rented | OR | 4.47 | Sidebotham et al. 2002 | ||
65 | Social Network Score | Maltreatment of Children | Other | <21 | OR | 3.09 (1.84 - 5.19) | Sidebotham et al. 2002 | ||
66 | Parental unemployement | Maltreatment of Children | Other | yes/no | OR | 2.33 | Sidebotham et al. 2002 | ||
67 | Car use | Maltreatment of Children | Other | yes/no | OR | 2.23 | Sidebotham et al. 2002 | ||
68 | house dampness | headache | inhalation, other | yes/no | OR | 8.7 (8.1 - 9.3) | Packer et al. 1994 | ||
69 | Smoking | mental problems | inhalation | yes/no | OR | 8 (0.4 - 15.6) | Packer et al. 1994 | ||
70 | Social life | health problems | other | <21 | OR | 11.8 (5.8 - 17.8) | Packer et al. 1994 | ||
71 | Alcohol | health problems | other | yes/no | OR | 0.1 (5.3 - 5.5) | Packer et al. 1994 | ||
72 | Lone adult | health problems | other | yes/no | OR | 12.1 | Packer et al. 1994 | ||
73 | Unemployment seeking work | health problems | other | yes/no | OR | 6.9 | Packer et al. 1994 |
Note 1 ERF of indoor dampness on respiratory health effects
Note 2 WP6 well-being report (password-protected)
Note 3 ERF of PM2.5 on mortality in general population
Note 4 Concentration-response to PM2.5
Note 5 Health impact of radon in Europe
Rationale
An example for RefTaq functionality: Pope et al. (2002) [1]
Juho Kutvonen and Salla Mönkkönen Hopton and Hunt (1996) [2]
Isabell Rumrich and Stefania Caporaso Sidebotham et al. (2002) [3]
Soroush Majlesi and Adnan Ahmad Packer et al. (1994) [4]
Jukka Hirvonen and Sami Rissanen Blackman et al. (2001) [5]
Precision and Plausability of Hopton and Hunt (1996)
- Reporting bias: Perhaps ít´s difficult to use subjective data due to reporting bias. This is because people may answer in different ways or they don´t answer at all. In addition, people experience household conditions differently.
- Possible confounding variables were controlled.
- Selection bias: The sample is clearly not representative of the general population and therefore the analysis focuses on differences within the sample. Thus it´s worth considering if the results can be generalized to whole population.
Precision and Plausability of Sidebotham et al. (2002)
- maltreatment: registration for physical injury, neglect, sexual abuse, emotional abuse
- social class: no allowance for nonworking mothers, no parental social class allocated for single mothers
- nature of relationship with child maltreatment is complex (confounder, cultural values, etc)
- income is not measured directly, but car ownership as a proxy indicator and receipt of welfare payment
- controlling for social factors
- large amount of prospectively collect data
- participation is lower among the maltreated group
- risk of social bias and no way of measuring the effect of such bias
Precision and Plausability of Packer et al. (1994)
- health problems: possibility of headache, mental problems, emotional reactions, social isolation and pain.
- social factors: unemployment, single parent, lone adult and unemployment with sickness or disability
- lifestyle: consumption of alcohol and smoking
- it is still difficult to understand the housing condition because none of the studies are complete and detailed so that direct comparison with the questions cannot be made and measurements of parameters, potential confounding factors as well as clear dose-response relationship should be adjusted for example physical effect of damp is responsible for muscle tension, backache and headache but on the other hand the study poins out that there is a strong relationship between damp housing and adverse health impact.
Dependencies
Formula
See also
Keywords
References
- ↑ *Pope CA III, Burnett RT, Thun MJ, Calle EE, Krewski D, Ito K & Thurston KD (2002). Lung cancer, cardiopulmonary mortality, and long-term exposure to fine particulate air pollution. JAMA 287(9), 1132-1141.
- ↑ *Hopton J.L. and Hunt S.M.(1996). Housing conditions and mental health in a disadvantaged area in Scotland. Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health 1996;50:56-61
- ↑ *Sidebotham et al. (2002). Child maltreatment in the “Children of the Nineties:” deprivation, class, and social networks in a UK sample.Child Abuse and Neglect 2002;26:1243-1259
- ↑ *Packer et al. Damp housing and adult health: results from a lifestyle study in Worcester, England.Journal of epidemiology and community health 1994;48(6):555–559
- ↑ *Blackman T, Harvey J, Lawrence M & Simon A. (2001). Neighbourhood renewal and health: evidence from a local case study. Health & Place 7(2001), 93-103.
Related files
<mfanonymousfilelist></mfanonymousfilelist>