View source for Talk:Trip rate on a workday in the Helsinki metropolitan area

== moved from [[Talk:Composite traffic]] ==

==About the focus==

{{discussion|
Statements = Total number of trips travelled per hour in the Helsinki Metropolitan Area.|
Resolution = Total number of composite trips travelled per hour in the Helsinki Metropolitan Area.|
Argumentation =
{{Attack|1|The focus  is ambiguous. It should be mentioned that the trips are only composite trips, not all. Rewording is needed.|Juha}}
:{{Defend_invalid|2| Focus should be short and easily understandable. Details about the essence of the variable should be in the scope, not in the focus.|--[[User:Jouni|Jouni]] 22:33, 17 September 2006 (EEST)}}
::{{Attack|3| This alternative is almost as short, so the argument does not hold: "Total number of composite trips travelled per hour in the Helsinki Metropolitan Area".|Juha}}
}}

==Scope should not contain assumptions about composite fraction==

{{discussion|
Statements = Scope: "Trips of one working day, based on year 2000 data. Private car trips as the starting point; 50% of them were assumed to switch to composite traffic." Scope should not contain assumptions about composite fraction.|
Resolution = |
Argumentation =
{{Defend|1| Assumption of composite fraction is of a very detailed operational nature, and it should not be in the scope.|Juha}}
}}