Risks and benefits related to consumption of vegetables

From Opasnet
Revision as of 11:18, 13 March 2009 by Päivi Meriläinen (talk | contribs)
(diff) ← Older revision | Latest revision (diff) | Newer revision → (diff)
Jump to navigation Jump to search

Scope

To perform a benefit-risk assessment in order to find out what would be the effects of additional vitamins, either in form of fortified foods or vitamin supplements, to children having a low vegetable diet (low vegetable diet assumed to be a junk-food rich diet).


Definition

Boundaries

  • target age group: children 6 years
  • countries: Finland, Ireland, Denmark, and Spain
  • vitamins: A (beta-carotene), B6, C, D

expected/considered effects/impacts:

    • vitamin D overdose
    • vitamin A, B6, C, D deficiency
    • effects of sugar and fat in diet
    • life-long impacts: obesity, CVD, type 2 diabetes

Time limits for case (agreed milestones/deliverables):

  • A summary table of the most important risks and benefits of vegetables vs. supplements and food fortification promised on month 18 (could this be replaced with the case research plan including the rationale behind scoping etc.?)
  • Final product (D40 Full benefit-risk analysis: vegetables) ready by month 34

Scenarios

  1. BAU (description current situation)
  2. vitamin addition(s) of given amount(s) to children belonging to low vegetable diet category

Intended users

possible target groups for using the information (prioritisation needed):

  • children's educators: school teachers, school health care personnel
  • public health care personnel
  • Parents of the children
  • decision-makers on vitamin supplement and food fortification regulations
  • food producers
  • vitamin supplement producers

Participants

Participating project members/person months:

  • KTL | 7
  • TUDelft | 0
  • FFiles | 0
  • FSAI | 1
  • DTU | 1
  • FVST | 0
  • Lendac | 0
  • FIN | 2
  • case study will be carried out openly (will be carried out on open website: http://en.opasnet.org)
  • any participants among the identified potential user groups to be invited?
  • any participants among the target group (children of age 6) to be invited?

Data

Decision variables

  • Vitamin addition to a child's diet, either
    • in form of fortified foods (food fortification?)
    • in form of vitamin supplements

Indicators

Other variables

Analyses

  • Prioritisation on the most important effects and uncertainties will be done using value-of-information method and other techniques

Causality

Unit

Formula

Result

Results of the analyses

Conclusions

See also

References