Axioms of open assessment: Difference between revisions

From Opasnet
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(first draft based on own thinking)
 
(→‎Result: Last Thursdayism and Trialogue added)
Line 15: Line 15:


Axioms of open assessment:
Axioms of open assessment:
* There is a reality where all things are and everything happens.
* There is exactly one reality where all things are and everything happens.
* There is I, an individual that can think (in the sense of [[:en:Descartes|Descartes]]' "Cogito, ergo sum").
* There is I, an individual that can think (in the sense of [[:en:Descartes|Descartes]]' ''Cogito, ergo sum'').
* I have senses that I can use to observe reality.
* I have senses that I can use to observe reality.
* Observations give me information (although imperfect) about reality.
* Observations give me information (although imperfect) about reality.
* I have comprension that I can use to develop a description about what reality is based on the information I obtain.
* I have comprension that I can use to develop a description about what reality is based on the information I obtain.
* Reality is a continuum in the sense that there are no discontinuous events where e.g. objects suddenly appear to or disappear from existence without a reason.
* Reality is a continuum in the sense that there are no discontinuous events where e.g. objects suddenly appear to or disappear from existence without a reason (compare to [[:en:Omphalos hypothesis#Other formulations|Last Thursdayism]]).
* There are other individuals who also can observe reality, collect information and develop descriptions about reality.
* There are other individuals who also can observe reality, collect information and develop descriptions about reality.
* An individual can observe also other individuals and communicate his/her observations and descriptions of reality to others.
* An individual can observe also other individuals, communicate his/her observations and descriptions of reality to others. Therefore, he/she can thus develop understanding of the reality based on own and communicated observations and reasoning in the spirit of [[Trialogue]].
* There is at least some truth value in the descriptions of other individuals. In other words, the other individuals do not together and systematically attempt to describe reality to me in a way that is different than what they describe it to themselves (compare the situation in the movie [[:en:Truman show|Truman show]]).
* There is at least some truth value in the descriptions of other individuals. In other words, the other individuals do not together and systematically attempt to describe reality to me in a way that is different than what they describe it to themselves (compare the situation in the movie [[:en:Truman show|Truman show]]).



Revision as of 19:04, 20 February 2009


Scope

What are the statements that cannot be evaluated scientifically but are necessary for a coherent open assessment system?

Definition

Data

Result

Axioms of open assessment:

  • There is exactly one reality where all things are and everything happens.
  • There is I, an individual that can think (in the sense of Descartes' Cogito, ergo sum).
  • I have senses that I can use to observe reality.
  • Observations give me information (although imperfect) about reality.
  • I have comprension that I can use to develop a description about what reality is based on the information I obtain.
  • Reality is a continuum in the sense that there are no discontinuous events where e.g. objects suddenly appear to or disappear from existence without a reason (compare to Last Thursdayism).
  • There are other individuals who also can observe reality, collect information and develop descriptions about reality.
  • An individual can observe also other individuals, communicate his/her observations and descriptions of reality to others. Therefore, he/she can thus develop understanding of the reality based on own and communicated observations and reasoning in the spirit of Trialogue.
  • There is at least some truth value in the descriptions of other individuals. In other words, the other individuals do not together and systematically attempt to describe reality to me in a way that is different than what they describe it to themselves (compare the situation in the movie Truman show).

See also

References