Welcome to Opasnet: Difference between revisions

From Opasnet
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(discussion instructions moved to Discussion)
(wikipedia/opasnet comparison moved to Opasnet, descriptions of use-levels added)
Line 1: Line 1:
== What is Opasnet? ==
== What is Opasnet? ==


'''Opasnet''' is a wiki-based website for helping decisions about human health, and environmental factors affecting it. The website collects, synthesises, and distributes people's values and scientific information. We believe that all wise decision-making is based on expressing our values about what the really important things are, and understanding how the decision actually affects those things. This is why we need both values and science.
'''Opasnet''' is a wiki-based website for supporting decisions about human health, and environmental factors affecting it. The website collects, synthesizes, and communicates people's values and scientific information. We believe that all wise decision-making is based on expressing our values about what the really important things are, and understanding how the decision actually affects those things. This is why we need both values and science.


Opasnet is hosted by [http://www.ktl.fi/portal/english/ THL] (National Institute for Health and Welfare, Finland). [http://www.ktl.fi/portal/english/osiot/research,_people___programs/environmental_health/ The Department of Environmental Health] has a motto: 
Opasnet is hosted by [http://www.ktl.fi/portal/english/ THL] (National Institute for Health and Welfare, Finland). [http://www.ktl.fi/portal/english/osiot/research,_people___programs/environmental_health/ The Department of Environmental Health] has a motto: 


:Man must be able to breathe, drink, eat and live in the environment trusting on its safety. This is both individual's civil right and a prerequisite for a functioning society and economy.
:Man must be able to breathe, drink, eat and live in the environment trusting on its safety. This is both an individual's civil right and a prerequisite for a functioning society and economy.


This is a major challenge. We must ensure that the environment is safe in general. We must teach people to avoid things in the environment that are not healthy. We must be alert for emerging hazards and be prepared when needed. And we must convince people that when all this has been done, they don't need to worry.
This is a major challenge. Firstly, we must try to ensure that the environment is safe in general. Secondly, we must provide the people the means to avoiding things in the environment that put their health at risk. Thirdly, we must be alert and try to identify emerging hazards and be prepared when needed. Finally, when all this has been done, we must also manage to communicate to the people that they do not need to worry.


By this website, we hope to provide understanding on and guidance for environmental health issues and decision-making. The issues are usually very complex and cross administrative, geographical, and scientific boundaries. Therefore we need information and contributions from many disciplines and areas. This website is built in a way that hopefully makes it easy for you to add information and values. It is also built in a way that mimics the real world. The pages describe things that are usually real, measurable quantities. And if something affects something else, these two things should be linked also in this website. It is a major challenge to describe even the most crucial things affecting human health, but that is what we are aiming to do. We have started from practical case studies to make this effort somewhat manageable.
By means of this website, we hope to provide understanding on and guidance for environmental health issues and decision making regarding them. The issues are usually very complex and they tend to cross administrative, geographical, and scientific boundaries. Therefore we need information and contributions from many different disciplines and areas of societal action. This website is built in a way that hopefully makes it easy for anyone to add their information and values. It is also built in a way that attempts to mimic the real world. The pages describe things that are usually real, measurable quantities. And if something affects something else, these two things should also be linked in this website. It is a challenging task to describe even the most crucial things affecting human health, but that is what this website aims to do. We have started this work by carrying out practical case studies in order to make this effort somewhat manageable.


==What is the difference between Opasnet and Wikipedia?==
==How does Opasnet function?==


To our knowledge, Opasnet is a unique website in its aims and methods. However, in many ways it is also very similar to [[:en:Main page|Wikipedia]], which is a well-known concept. It might therefore be useful to compare Opasnet and Wikipedia.
Probably the most obvious point of comparison to '''Opasnet''' is '''[[:en:Main Page|Wikipedia]]''', the free encyclopedia that anyone can edit. Both of them are web-based information storages and workspaces building on the idea of open mass collaboration. The main difference between Opasnet and Wikipedia is that, whereas the Wikipedia is an encyclopedia, i.e. a relatively freely formatted information repository of any topic for any purpose, the purpose of Opasnet is to provide information to support decision making by means of systematic analysis. Due to this difference, both the information within Opasnet and the use of Opasnet is somewhat more structured. For a more detailed comparison between Opasnet and Wikipedia as well as more information about the structure of Opasnet, see a separate page that explains [[Opasnet]] in more detail.
# The purpose of Wikipedia is to provide information in general. The purpose of Opasnet is to give guidance to decision-making related to environment and health.
# Wikipedia is an encyclopedia. Opasnet is more like a decision support system (although the structure is quite different than in typical decision support systems). However, Opasnet also has some encyclopedia-like contents.
# Both Wikipedia and Opasnet are running on [http://www.mediawiki.org Mediawiki] software.
# Wikipedia rejects information that is not established. Opasnet collects also controversial information but with a certain structure that reveals the controversies. There are also rules that try to solve or at least diminish these controversies.
# Wikipedia describes everything from [[:en:neutral point of view|neutral point of view]]. Opasnet does the same for the scientific content, but it also collects values where neutrality is not required. However, respect to other people's values and relevance to the topic are always required.
# In Wikipedia, the content is structured as articles. In Opasnet, there are also encyclopedia-like pages, but the major content is a structured collection of real-world measurable quantities. We call them [[help:variable|variables]]. A synthesis of these variables forms an analysis of a particular decision situation and gives guidance and information for the decision.
# Wikipedia collects existing information. Opasnet creates also new information by combining existing information into novel syntheses.
# A Wikipedia page has links to other pages whenever associations exist. A Opasnet page has the same, but in addition, there are special kinds of links that describe '''causal''' connections between things. There are special rules about how to describe these connectioins.
# Wikipedia has Talk pages for discussions about the content. Opasnet has them also, but the discussions have more specific rules. Discussions are used especially for formal [[help:argumentation|argumentation]] about defined topics.
# Anyone can edit Wikipedia. Opasnet also has an open policy for contributions, but we require that editors use their real names. In addition, many pages are protected in such a way that only a draft page can be edited, and the contents are regularly moved to the actual page by the administrators (in a similar way as in Citizendium). This is because the pages have more complicated technical requirements than in Wikipedia, and unskilled authors could disrupt the structure.


== How can you participate? ==
There are several possible ways of making use of Opasnet:
 
# '''Read''' Opasnet. Browse through the pages and obtain information of your interest. A good way to get started is by following the links on [[Main Page]]. Another efficient way of getting acquainted with the information content is to have a look at the categories and pages belonging to different categories by following the ''Main category'' link in the navigation toolbar on the left hand side. One can also make word searches using the ''search'' text box in the navigation toolbar on the left. Opasnet is in the open internet and reading Opasnet is unlimited.
* [[Discussion|Contribute to a discussion]]
# '''Comment''' Opasnet content. Every page in Opasnet has a corresponding [[Discussion|discussion]] page. In order to be able to write to Opasnet, one needs to be registered and logged in. [[Special:Userlogin| Create an account]] and click the ''discussion'' link on top of the particular page whose content you wish to comment. Then click the ''edit'' link on top of the discussion page and write your comment in the edit window. See [[Help:Contents|help pages]] for guidance on writing to Opasnet. Opasnet recommends a formal [[Discussion|'''argumentation''']] format for discussions, but also freely formatted comments are acceptable, but be aware that your comment may be transformed into a formal argumentation structure by some other user.
# '''Edit''' Opasnet pages. When logged in, also the actual content pages become editable. Note that it is often recommended to write down comments on the discussion page before proceeding to edit the page itself. However if you are convinced that you know what you are doing, please go ahead and make your edits. Opasnet records a complete version history of all pages so no need to be too worried about causing any irreversible harm.
# '''Create''' new pages to Opasnet. In the navigation toolbar in the left, there is a ''create new pages'' link that takes to a page where a name of a new page can be given and an object-type category can be chosen for the page. It is recommended that before proceeding to create new pages, one becomes sufficiently acquainted with the [[Category:Object type| object types]] and their uses in Opasnet as well as the principles and methods of [[Open assessment|open assessment]].
# '''Use''' the information created in and obtained from Opasnet. The purpose of Opasnet is to provide support to decision making and thereby guide actions.

Revision as of 13:22, 17 April 2009

What is Opasnet?

Opasnet is a wiki-based website for supporting decisions about human health, and environmental factors affecting it. The website collects, synthesizes, and communicates people's values and scientific information. We believe that all wise decision-making is based on expressing our values about what the really important things are, and understanding how the decision actually affects those things. This is why we need both values and science.

Opasnet is hosted by THL (National Institute for Health and Welfare, Finland). The Department of Environmental Health has a motto:

Man must be able to breathe, drink, eat and live in the environment trusting on its safety. This is both an individual's civil right and a prerequisite for a functioning society and economy.

This is a major challenge. Firstly, we must try to ensure that the environment is safe in general. Secondly, we must provide the people the means to avoiding things in the environment that put their health at risk. Thirdly, we must be alert and try to identify emerging hazards and be prepared when needed. Finally, when all this has been done, we must also manage to communicate to the people that they do not need to worry.

By means of this website, we hope to provide understanding on and guidance for environmental health issues and decision making regarding them. The issues are usually very complex and they tend to cross administrative, geographical, and scientific boundaries. Therefore we need information and contributions from many different disciplines and areas of societal action. This website is built in a way that hopefully makes it easy for anyone to add their information and values. It is also built in a way that attempts to mimic the real world. The pages describe things that are usually real, measurable quantities. And if something affects something else, these two things should also be linked in this website. It is a challenging task to describe even the most crucial things affecting human health, but that is what this website aims to do. We have started this work by carrying out practical case studies in order to make this effort somewhat manageable.

How does Opasnet function?

Probably the most obvious point of comparison to Opasnet is Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia that anyone can edit. Both of them are web-based information storages and workspaces building on the idea of open mass collaboration. The main difference between Opasnet and Wikipedia is that, whereas the Wikipedia is an encyclopedia, i.e. a relatively freely formatted information repository of any topic for any purpose, the purpose of Opasnet is to provide information to support decision making by means of systematic analysis. Due to this difference, both the information within Opasnet and the use of Opasnet is somewhat more structured. For a more detailed comparison between Opasnet and Wikipedia as well as more information about the structure of Opasnet, see a separate page that explains Opasnet in more detail.

There are several possible ways of making use of Opasnet:

  1. Read Opasnet. Browse through the pages and obtain information of your interest. A good way to get started is by following the links on Main Page. Another efficient way of getting acquainted with the information content is to have a look at the categories and pages belonging to different categories by following the Main category link in the navigation toolbar on the left hand side. One can also make word searches using the search text box in the navigation toolbar on the left. Opasnet is in the open internet and reading Opasnet is unlimited.
  2. Comment Opasnet content. Every page in Opasnet has a corresponding discussion page. In order to be able to write to Opasnet, one needs to be registered and logged in. Create an account and click the discussion link on top of the particular page whose content you wish to comment. Then click the edit link on top of the discussion page and write your comment in the edit window. See help pages for guidance on writing to Opasnet. Opasnet recommends a formal argumentation format for discussions, but also freely formatted comments are acceptable, but be aware that your comment may be transformed into a formal argumentation structure by some other user.
  3. Edit Opasnet pages. When logged in, also the actual content pages become editable. Note that it is often recommended to write down comments on the discussion page before proceeding to edit the page itself. However if you are convinced that you know what you are doing, please go ahead and make your edits. Opasnet records a complete version history of all pages so no need to be too worried about causing any irreversible harm.
  4. Create new pages to Opasnet. In the navigation toolbar in the left, there is a create new pages link that takes to a page where a name of a new page can be given and an object-type category can be chosen for the page. It is recommended that before proceeding to create new pages, one becomes sufficiently acquainted with the and their uses in Opasnet as well as the principles and methods of open assessment.
  5. Use the information created in and obtained from Opasnet. The purpose of Opasnet is to provide support to decision making and thereby guide actions.