Human PBPK model for dioxin

This page is a knowledge crystal of subtype method. The page identifier is Op_en1947
Moderator:Jouni (see all)
Upload data {{#opasnet_base_link:Op_en1947}}

Question

How to calculate dioxin concentrations in human tissues after a given exposure pattern?

Answer

These are several approaches available.

• INERIS (France) has produced a TOXI/INERIS model.
• Aylward (2005a, b) have described a model.

Tuomisto et al model

This model was previously on page Dioxin.

Dioxin parameters(%,-,d-1,a)

Obs	Congener	Market basket	TEF	Elimination constant	Half life
1	TCDD	2	1	0.00026	7.3
2	12378PeCDD	2	1	0.00017	11.2
3	123678HxCDD	5	0.1	0.000145	13.1
4	1234678HpCDD	7	0.001	0.00039	4.9
5	OCDD	60	0.0003	0.00028	6.8
6	TCDF	8	0.1	0.0009	2.1
7	23478PeCDF	16	0.3	0.00027	7.0

The daily dose of dioxins (WHO-TEq): Weight increase (g per year): Body fat in the beginning (g): congeners: TCDD 12378PeCDD 123678HxCDD 1234678HpCDD OCDD TCDF 23478PeCDF + Show code- Hide code library(OpasnetUtils) library(ggplot2) ####### FETCH AND MODIFY INPUTS parameters <- opbase.data("Op_en1947.dioxin_parameters") parameters$Obs <- NULL congeners <- Ovariable("congeners", data = data.frame(Congener = congeners, Result = 1)) TEF <- Ovariable("TEF", data = parameters[parameters$Observation == "TEF" , colnames(parameters) != "Observation"] ) share <- Ovariable("share", data = parameters[parameters$Observation == "Market basket" , colnames(parameters) != "Observation"] ) share <- share * TEF * congeners share <- share / oapply(share, cols = "Congener", FUN = sum) dose <- dose * 365 * share # From days to years and congener-specific doses ke <- Ovariable("ke", data = parameters[parameters$Observation == "Elimination constant" , colnames(parameters) != "Observation"] ) ke <- ke * 365 # from days to year time <- Ovariable("time", data = data.frame(Time = 0:50, Result = 0:50)) concentration <- Ovariable("concentration", dependencies = data.frame(Name = c("ke", "dose", "weight.increase", "fat", "time")), formula = function(...) { out <- dose / ke * # Dioxin amount in steady state (1 - exp(-1 * ke * time)) / # Fraction of steady state reached at time 'time'. (fat + weight.increase * time) # Amount converted to fat concentration. return(out) } ) concentration <- EvalOutput(concentration) ggplot(concentration@output, aes(x = timeResult, y = concentrationResult, colour = Congener)) + geom_line() + theme_gray(base_size = 28) + labs(y = "Concentration (pg /g fat)", x = "Years of exposure")

Dioxin kinetics with Bayes

+ Show code- Hide code ##################################### JAGS library(rjags) nonadat <- dat[ !is.na(dat$WHOTEQ) & !is.na(dat$Silmaara) & !is.na(dat$Kalteq) & !is.na(dat$ika) , ] N <- nrow(nonadat) mo <- textConnection("model { for (i in 1:N) { teq[i] ~ dnorm(mu[i], taut) mu[i] <- (dose[i] / (r - k) * # Dioxin amount in steady state (although it is not steady of r != 0) (exp((r - k) * time[i]) - 1) + # Fraction of steady state reached during the period. m * exp(-1 * k * time[i])) / # Residual amount from the beginning. (fat + weight.increase * time[i]) # Amount converted to fat concentration. } # m ~ dnorm(0, 0.0001) m <- 0 r <- 0.03 taut <- pow(sigmat, -2) sigmat ~ dunif(0, 100) fat <- 20000 weight.increase <- 0 k ~ dunif(0.05, 0.15) }") jags <- jags.model(mo, data = list( teq = nonadat$WHOTEQ, # sil = nonadat$Silmaara, dose = nonadat$Kalteq, time = nonadat$ika, N = N), n.chains = 4, n.adapt = 100 ) close(mo) #update(jags, 1000) out <- coda.samples(jags, c('m', 'taut', 'k'), nrow(nonadat)) # Stores a posterior sample plot(out) prediction <- function(dat, est) { est <- as.data.frame(est[[1]]) k <- est$k teq <- dat$WHOTEQ # sil <- dat$Silmaara dose <- dat$Kalteq time <- dat$ika fat <- 20000 weight.increase <- 0 m <- 0 r <- 0.03 i <- 1:nrow(dat) dat$mu <- (dose[i] / (r - k) * # Dioxin amount in steady state (although it is not steady of r != 0) (exp((r - k) * time[i]) - 1) + # Fraction of steady state reached during the period. m * exp(-1 * k * time[i])) / # Residual amount from the beginning. (fat + weight.increase * time[i]) # Amount converted to fat concentration. p <- ggplot(dat, aes(x = WHOTEQ, y = mu)) + geom_point() print(p) cat("Pearson\n") print(cor(dat[c("WHOTEQ", "mu")])) cat("Spearman\n") print(cor(dat[c("WHOTEQ", "mu")], method = "spearman")) } prediction(nonadat, out)

Aylward et al model

Measured TCDD concentration (ng/kg bw): Follow-up time since the measurement (a). May be negative.: Exposure in exposure scores (unit/a): What variables do you want to show on timeline graph?: Body burden Liver concentration Fat concentration Fraction of body weight in fat Elimination rate from liver + Show code- Hide code library(reshape2) ##### f.h a function for fraction of TCDD in liver. Parameters: # C.b Concentration of TCDD in body (ng/kg) # f.h.min Minimum proportion of body burden distributed to liver (unitless) # f.h.max Maximum proportion of body burden distributed to liver (unitless) # K Body concentration for half-maximum increase in liver distribution (ng/kg) f.h <- function(C.b, f.h.min = 0.01, f.h.max = 0.7, K = 100){ out <- f.h.min + (f.h.max - f.h.min) * C.b / (K + C.b) return(out) } ##### ##### C.bt a function for calculating body concentration of TCDD. Parameters: # C.b Body concentration of TCDD at time point t # time length of follow-up time (a). May also be negative. # beta Dose rate or amount of TCDD per one exposure unit (ng/unit) # E.t Exposure measured in exposure units (unit/a) # BW Body weight (kg) # k.e Hepatic elimination (1/a) # k.a Adipose elimination (1/a) # C.at Adipose concentration of TCDD (ng/kg) # w.a Fraction of body weight in adipose tissue (unitless) # w.h Fraction of body weight in liver (unitless) C.bt <- function(C.b, time = 10, E.t = 1, beta = 134, BW = 70, k.a = 0.01, k.e0 = 0.85, k.emin = 0.2, BMI = 24, age = 30, sex = 1, w.h = 0.03){ t <- (0:(time*12))/12 dt <- time/abs(time)/12 out <- data.frame(Time = t, w.a = NA, C.a = NA, C.b = NA, C.h = NA, k.e = NA) for(i in 1:length(t)){ f.he <- f.h(C.b) k.e <- max(k.e0 - 0.011 * age, k.emin) w.a <- (1.2 * BMI + 0.23 * age - 10.8*sex - 5.4)/100 C.a <- C.b * (1 - f.he) / w.a C.h <- C.b * f.he / w.h out[i, 2:ncol(out)] <- c(w.a, C.a, C.b, C.h, k.e) C.b <- C.b + beta * E.t * dt / BW - k.e * dt * f.he * C.b - k.a * dt * C.a * w.a age <- age + dt } return(out) } out <- C.bt(C.b, E.t = E.t, time = time) head(out) out <- melt(out, id.vars = "Time") colnames(out) <- c("DateTime", "TagName", "Value") out <- dropall(out[out$TagName %in% select, ]) cat("Figure 1. Variables as functions of time. C.b: body burden of TCDD, C.h and C.a: liver and fat concentrations of TCDD, respectively, k.e elimination rate, a.w fraction of body weight in fat.\n") multivarplot(out) C.b <- out[out$TagName == "C.b", "Value"] C.b <- min(C.b):max(C.b) cat("Figure 2. Fraction of body TCDD in liver as a function of body burden.\n") plot(C.b, f.h(C.b))

TOXI/INERIS model

Dioxin PBPK model
The results are total amounts (ng) of dioxin, except blood concentration (ng/l). See the model documentation
The input data used for this variable: Intake at age 0 - 5 a (ng/min) 0.000173611 Intake at age 5 - 10 a (ng/min) 0.000173611 Intake at age 10-15 a (ng/min) 0.000173611 Intake at age 15 - 40 a (ng/min) 0.000173611 Intake at age 40 - a (ng/min) 0.000173611 Start of peak intake (days) 100 End of peak intake (days) 1000 Additional peak intake (ng/min) 0.000001
Click here to run the model

Rationale

Tuomisto et al

This model is based on one-compartment kinetics with a dioxin intake trend (r %/a decrease). The amount of dioxin in the body now (m₀) from a dose d_i at a timepoint ('now' is t=0 and t_i is the time since the timepoint, i indicating different timepoints) is calculated as follows, if the dose during time decreases at a constant rate r:

Failed to parse (SVG (MathML can be enabled via browser plugin): Invalid response ("Math extension cannot connect to Restbase.") from server "https://wikimedia.org/api/rest_v1/":): {\displaystyle m_0 = d_i e^{-k t_i} = d_0 e^{r t_i} e^{-k t_i} = d_0 e^{(r-k) t_i}.}

The total amount of dioxin M₀ from all doses during the time period is

Failed to parse (SVG (MathML can be enabled via browser plugin): Invalid response ("Math extension cannot connect to Restbase.") from server "https://wikimedia.org/api/rest_v1/":): {\displaystyle M_0 = \Sigma_{i=1}^n d_0 e^{(r-k) t_i} = \int_0^t d_0 e^{(r-k) t_i}dt = d_0 \frac{e^{(r-k) t}}{r-k} - d_0 \frac{e^{(r-k) 0}}{r-k} = d_0 \frac{e^{(r-k) t}-1}{r-k}.}

There may also be previous dioxin load at t_i, and this is denoted m_i:

Failed to parse (SVG (MathML can be enabled via browser plugin): Invalid response ("Math extension cannot connect to Restbase.") from server "https://wikimedia.org/api/rest_v1/":): {\displaystyle M_0 = d_0 \frac{e^{(r-k) t}-1}{r-k} + m_i e^{-k t}.}

If the intake is constant, this simplifies into

Failed to parse (SVG (MathML can be enabled via browser plugin): Invalid response ("Math extension cannot connect to Restbase.") from server "https://wikimedia.org/api/rest_v1/":): {\displaystyle M_0 = \frac{d_0}{k} (1 - e^{-k t}) + m_i e^{-k t},}

where d₀/k is the steady state amount at constant intake, (1 - e^{-k t}) is the relative deviation from the steady state, and m_i e^{-k t} is the additional burden from before.

Assumptions

• WHO-TEQ intake 57 pg/d average (Kiviranta et al, Env Int 2004:30:923)
  • low intake 40 pg/d (42,05)
  • high intake 160 pg/d (168,2)
• Average distribution 56 pg/d animal products, 1 pg/d plant products (ibid)
  • low intake 39 pg/d animal products, 1 pg/d plant products
  • high intake 157 pg/d animal products, 3 pg/d plant products
• Congener distribution as pg TEQ (rounded)
  • low intake TCDD 7,9, 12378PCDD 7,9, 123678HxCDD 2, 1234678HpCDD 0,03, OCDD 0,07, TCDF 3,2, 23478PeCDF 19 pg/d WHO-TEQ
  • high intake TCDD 32, 12378PCDD 32, 123678HxCDD 8, 1234678HpCDD 0,1, OCDD 0,3, TCDF 12,6, 23478PeCDF 76 pg/d WHO-TEQ
• Congener distribution as pg (rounded, rounded numbers used in other sheets)
  • low intake TCDD 7,9, 12378PCDD 7,9, 123678HxCDD 20, 1234678HpCDD 28, OCDD 237, TCDF 32, 23478PeCDF 63 pg/d
  • high intake TCDD 32, 12378PCDD 32, 123678HxCDD 80, 1234678HpCDD 111, OCDD 948, TCDF 126, 23478PeCDF 253 pg/d
• Congener elimination constants (d-1) TCDD 0,00026, 12378PCDD 0,00017, 123678HxCDD 0,000145, 1234678HpCDD 0,00039, OCDD 0,00028, TCDF 0,0009, 23478PeCDF 0,00027
  • Half lives from Milbrath et al., Environ. Health Persp. 2009:117:417-425

TOXI/INERIS

Basic info

Last modification:	04/07/2007	Model version :
Software status :	Free software	OS :	Linux
Supplier :	INERIS	Installation :	See source
Possible developments :	yes	Source :	TOXI/INERIS web site
Supplier address:	INERIS Verneuil en Halatte, France	Referent(s)* :	S. MICALLEF (INERIS) Sandrine.micallef@ineris.fr

Discipline : keywords: toxicokinetic model, 2,3,7,8-tétra-chloro-p-dioxin (TCDD), PBPK

Scope of the mode

Physiologically Based Toxicokinetic (PBTK) model for Dioxine. The presented PBTK model allows to simulate ingestion exposures to 2,3,7,8-tétra-chloro-p-dioxin (TCDD) for a woman over her whole life. TCDD is a persistent chemical found in trace amounts all over the globe. It accumulates in animal fat all along the trophic chain. Human exposure to TCDD is therefore almost unavoidable, even if in trace amounts. TCDD has multiple effects on health.

Model description

The proposed model is based on a previous one proposed by van der Molen and colleagues in 1996. The model computes various measures of internal dose as a function of time. The superposition of a peak exposure to a time-varying background intake can be described. All ingested TCDD is supposed to be absorbed. TCDD is supposed to distribute between blood, fat, muscles and skin, and viscera. The model equations are solved dynamically (by numerical integration) with the MCSim simulation package to give a good precision both on short-term and long-term scales. The body mass and the volume of the various body tissues change with the age of the simulated individual.

Figure 1 : Toxicokinetic model used to describe TCDD toxicokinetic in the human body. compartments are characterized with volume V and partition coefficient P. Exchanges between are governed by blood flows, F. Elimination is assumed proportional to the elimination constant, ke. The set value of each parameter is given in Table 1. The ingested quantity by unit of time ki (in ng/min), is determined by the exposure scenario.

Table 1 : Numerical values of the parameters of the toxicokinetic model for TCDD in the woman.

Parameter(a)	Symbol	Numerical Value
Ventilation rate	Fp	8,0
Blood over air ventilation rate	R	1,14
Blood flow rates
Fat	Ff	0,09
Liver	Fl	0,24
Muscles and skin	fm	0,18
Viscera	fv	– (b)
Volumes
Total body volume	Vt	– (c)
Fat	Vf	– (c)
Liver	Vl	– (c)
Muscles and skin	Vm	– (c)
Viscera	Vv	– (c)
Partition Coefficient
Fat	Pf	300
Liver	Pl	25
Muscles and skin	Pm	4
Viscera	Pv	10
Elimination constant	ke	8,45?10-8 (d)

(a) Units : volumes (L), blood flow (L/min), et elimination constant (min-1). (b) Blood flow rate to viscera is calculated by difference between 1 and the sum of blood flow rates toward the other compartments. (c) Volumes evolve with time. (d) Corresponds to a half-life of 15,6 years.

Figure 1 gives a graphical representation of the model used. Only ingestion exposure is described in this model (the totality of the exposure dose is assumed to be absorbed). The TCDD is supposed to be distributed into different compartments of the body : blood, fat, muscles and skin. The original formulation of van der Molen and coll. regards all these compartments as being with balance in an instantaneous way. This assumption is acceptable only if slow evolutions of absorption are the limiting factor of the kinetics of the product. Since the simulation of a short peak of exposure interests us, we developed a traditional dynamic formulation, specifies at the same time on short scales of time and the long-term.

Model equations Equations defining the proposed model are the following : For quantites of TCDD in fat, viscera, muscle and skin, and liver : (1) (2) (3) (4) La concentration artérielle est calculée par : (5)

The cardiac output, Ft, is proportinal to the ventilation rate, Fp : (1) The body volume evolve as a function of age : (6) The volume of fat, viscera, liver also evolve as a function of age: (7) (8) (9) Volume of "muscles and skin" compartment is calculated as the difference between 90% of the total body volume (because bones are not included) and the other compartments : (10) Units used are : quantities of TCDD are expressed in ng, TCDD concentrations in ng/L, age in years volumes in liter, flows in L/min, the elimination constant in min-1, the ingested quantity by unit of time in ng/min. The body density is assumed equal to 1.

Figure 2 presents the temporal evolution of these parameters for a woman (the evolution is overall similar for a man). The reference averaged values used for the parameters not evolving with time are given in Table 1. The equations of the model were coded using the MCSim software.

Figure 2 : Temporal evolution of volumes for the woman. 

Validation

To be done

Applications examples

Example of the use of this model can be found in the paper by Bois

See also

• Van der Molen GW, Kooijman BALM, Wittsiepe J, et al. Estimation of dioxin and furan elimination rates with a pharmacokinetic model

JOURNAL OF EXPOSURE ANALYSIS AND ENVIRONMENTAL EPIDEMIOLOGY 10 (6): 579-585 Part 1 NOV-DEC 2000.

• Van der Molen GW, Kooijman SALM, Michalek JE, et al. The estimation of elimination rates of persistent compounds: A re-analysis of 2,3,7,8-tetrachlorodibenzo-p-dioxin levels in Vietnam veterans CHEMOSPHERE 37 (9-12): 1833-1844 OCT-NOV 1998.

Model inputs

All intakes are given in ng/min. A typical unit is pg/d; to change from the latter to the former, divide by 1440000.

Background exposure parameters:

• dose1: intake of dioxin during age 0 - 5 years
• dose2: intake of dioxin during age 5 - 10 years
• dose3: intake of dioxin during age 10 -15 years
• dose4: intake of dioxin during age 15 - 40 years
• dose5: intake of dioxin during age 40 - years

Peak exposure parameters (in addition to the background)

• peakstart: start of the peak exposure period (in days of age)
• peakend: end of the peak exposure period (in days of age)
• peakdose: Additional intake of dioxin during the peak period (in ng/min)