Cost effectiveness sensitivity: Difference between revisions

From Opasnet
Jump to navigation Jump to search
No edit summary
No edit summary
Line 21: Line 21:
   rows:
   rows:
   [1]  pcv10       
   [1]  pcv10       
   [2]  pcv10+19A direct effects
   [2]  pcv10 + 19A(direct effects only)
   [3]  pcv+6A       
   [3]  pcv10 + 6A       
   [4]  pcv10+19A(direct only)+6A
   [4]  pcv10 + 19A(direct only) + 6A
   [5]  pcv10+19A full   
   [5]  pcv10 + 19A(full)  
   [6]  pcv10+19Af+6=PCV13-3
   [6]  pcv10 + 19A(full) + 6A = PCV13 - 3


   columns:
   columns:
   [1]  pcv13-3      
   [1]  pcv13 - 3 (excluding serotype 3)   
   [2]  pcv13
   [2]  pcv13


   
   


                PCV13adv.inIPD  price of PCV13    ICER
                  PCV13adv.inIPD  price of PCV13    ICER
                   --------------   --------------   ---------------
                   ==============   ==============   ===============
                   PCV13-3  PCV13  PCV13-3  PCV13    PCV13-3  PCV13
                   PCV13-3  PCV13  PCV13-3  PCV13    PCV13-3  PCV13
                     ---    ---     -----   ---     -----    ----
                     ---    ---   ------- -----     -----    ----
   pcv10            12    150      18   38         8077    8077
   pcv10            12    150      18     38       8077    8077
   pcv10+19Ad        -2    134      17   37         7714    7714
   pcv10+19Ad        -2    134      17     37       7714    7714
   pcv10+6A          50    188      25   55       13590    13590
   pcv10+6A          50    188      25     55       13590    13590
   pcv10+19Ad+6A    32    169      24   52       12724    12724
   pcv10+19Ad+6A    32    169      24     52       12724    12724
   pcv10+19Af      -31    105      15   32         6198    6199
   pcv10+19Af      -31    105      15     32       6198    6199
   pcv10+19Af+6A      *    137        *   43           *    9672
   pcv10+19Af+6A      *    137        *     43           *    9672
                                  ----------------
                                   (PCV10 price=20)
                                   (PCV10 price=20)

Revision as of 09:35, 21 August 2014


The effects of alternative vaccine compositions on the outcomes of the cost-benefit analysis were assessed. Five modifications for PCV10 and one for PCV13 were considered

Conclusion: The assumption about serotype 3 in PCV13 is crucial. In addition, assumptions about the role of 6A in PCV10 is important.


 PCV13adv.inIPD 
   = (IPD under PCv10) - (IPD under PCV13)
   if positive, PCV13 saves IPD compared to PCV10
 price of PCV13 
   =  if PCV10 price set at 20e, what is the matching price for PCV13?
 ICER 
   = incremental cost-effectiveness ratio for PCV10 at price 20e
    (in this table, this value is also average cost per QALY)


 rows:
 [1]  pcv10       
 [2]  pcv10 + 19A(direct effects only)
 [3]  pcv10 + 6A      
 [4]  pcv10 + 19A(direct only) + 6A
 [5]  pcv10 + 19A(full)  
 [6]  pcv10 + 19A(full) + 6A = PCV13 - 3
 columns:
 [1]  pcv13 - 3 (excluding serotype 3)     
 [2]  pcv13


                 PCV13adv.inIPD   price of PCV13    ICER
                 ==============   ==============    ===============
                 PCV13-3  PCV13   PCV13-3  PCV13    PCV13-3   PCV13
                   ---     ---    -------  -----     -----     ----
  pcv10             12     150       18     38        8077     8077
  pcv10+19Ad        -2     134       17     37        7714     7714
  pcv10+6A          50     188       25     55       13590    13590
  pcv10+19Ad+6A     32     169       24     52       12724    12724
  pcv10+19Af       -31     105       15     32        6198     6199
  pcv10+19Af+6A      *     137        *     43           *     9672
                                 ----------------
                                 (PCV10 price=20)