Intarese framework: Difference between revisions
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
m (ref corrected) |
mNo edit summary |
||
(9 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown) | |||
Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
{{Guidebook}} | {{Guidebook}} | ||
[[Category:Assessment frameworks]] | |||
{{encyclopedia|moderator=Alexandra Kuhn}} | |||
[[Category:Glossary term]] | [[Category:Glossary term]] | ||
<section begin=glossary /> | |||
:'''The INTARESE framework''' comprises all relevant aspects and builds on all relevant methods to provide guidance for a comprehensive integrated environmental health impact assessment.<ref name="Intarese_framework">[http://www.intarese.org/kt/action.php?kt_path_info=ktcore.actions.document.view&fDocumentId=26 D5 Intarese Conceptual Model of Assessment Framework] (May 2007)</ref> It recognised the concept of the DPSIR, DPSEEA and MEME frameworks but provides a more flexible and comprehensive framework. The key [[Attribute | attributes]] are: | |||
:* the full chain approach, including variables and causal relationships linking the different steps in the chain from source to impact | :* the full chain approach, including variables and causal relationships linking the different steps in the chain from source to impact | ||
:* the logical process of assessment (steps involved in the execution of the assessment, tasks and responsibilities of the parties involved) | :* the logical process of assessment (steps involved in the execution of the assessment, tasks and responsibilities of the parties involved) | ||
Line 15: | Line 16: | ||
|- | |- | ||
! Framework | ! Framework | ||
! | ! Impact Pathway Approach | ||
! Full chain | ! Full chain | ||
! DPSIR | ! DPSIR | ||
Line 21: | Line 22: | ||
|- | |- | ||
| '''Used by whom''' | | '''Used by whom''' | ||
| '''ExternE | | '''ExternE''' | ||
| '''Intarese''' | | '''Intarese / Heimtsa''' | ||
| '''EEA''' | | '''EEA''' | ||
| '''WHO''' | | '''WHO''' | ||
Line 28: | Line 29: | ||
! '''Source''' | ! '''Source''' | ||
| <ref>http://www.externe.info/</ref> | | <ref>http://www.externe.info/</ref> | ||
| <ref>http://www.intarese.org</ref> | | <ref>http://www.intarese.org</ref> <ref>Briggs, D. (2008). "A framework for integrated environmental health impact assessment of systemic risks." Environmental Health 7:61. doi:10.1186/1476-069X-7-61</ref> | ||
| <ref>http://glossary.eea.europa.eu/EEAGlossary/D/DPSIR</ref> <ref>http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DPSIR</ref> <ref>http://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/DPSIR</ref> | | <ref>http://glossary.eea.europa.eu/EEAGlossary/D/DPSIR</ref> <ref>http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DPSIR</ref> <ref>http://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/DPSIR</ref> | ||
| <ref>http://www.euro.who.int/EHindicators/Indicators/20030527_2</ref> | | <ref>http://www.euro.who.int/EHindicators/Indicators/20030527_2</ref> | ||
Line 34: | Line 35: | ||
! '''Summary''' | ! '''Summary''' | ||
| The impact pathway approach allows for the determination of impacts (e.g. health effects) and damages (external costs) due to emissions of pollutants. | | The impact pathway approach allows for the determination of impacts (e.g. health effects) and damages (external costs) due to emissions of pollutants. | ||
| The full chain covers all the aspects from the other frameworks and focuses on comprehensiveness and integration. It is limited to human health. | | The full chain covers all the aspects from the other frameworks and focuses on comprehensiveness and integration. It acknowledges the importance of multi-causalities, complexity, interdependencies and uncertainty. It is limited to human health. | ||
| The causal framework for describing the interactions between society and the environment adopted by the European Environment Agency: driving forces, pressures, states, impacts, responses (extension of the PSR model developed by OECD). | | The causal framework for describing the interactions between society and the environment adopted by the European Environment Agency: driving forces, pressures, states, impacts, responses (extension of the PSR model developed by OECD). | ||
| The DPSEEA (Driving Forces - Pressures - State - Exposure - Effects - Actions) model is useful in designing a system of environmental health indicators within the decision-making context. | | The DPSEEA (Driving Forces - Pressures - State - Exposure - Effects - Actions) model is useful in designing a system of environmental health indicators within the decision-making context. | ||
|- | |- | ||
| colspan="5" | | | colspan="5" | | ||
|- | |||
! '''Scenarios''' | |||
| Scenario development / description: comparison of (a) policy option(s) to a reference scenario | |||
| Either consider the status quo or investigate scenarios | |||
| | |||
| | |||
|- | |- | ||
! '''Driving forces''' | ! '''Driving forces''' | ||
| '''Activities''' <br> Activities that lead to emissions, e.g. driving a car, producing energy, using hairspray | | '''Activities''' <br> Activities that lead to emissions, e.g. driving a car, producing energy, using hairspray | ||
| | | '''Activities''' <br> Activities that lead to emissions, e.g. driving a car, producing energy, using hairspray, natural activities like volcanoe eruptions | ||
| '''Driving forces''' <br> Areas in public life that exert pressure on the environment, e.g. economic sectors, households. | | '''Driving forces''' <br> Areas in public life that exert pressure on the environment, e.g. economic sectors, households. | ||
| '''Driving forces''' <br> The driving forces refer to the factors that motivate and push the environmental processes involved. | | '''Driving forces''' <br> The driving forces refer to the factors that motivate and push the environmental processes involved. | ||
Line 79: | Line 86: | ||
| | | | ||
| '''Responses''' <br> Social reaction to the burden, e.g. research and laws | | '''Responses''' <br> Social reaction to the burden, e.g. research and laws | ||
| '''Actions''' <br> In face of the environmental problems and consequent health effects, society attempts to adopt and implement a | | '''Actions''' <br> In face of the environmental problems and consequent health effects, society attempts to adopt and implement a range of actions. These may take many forms and be targeted at different points within the environment-health continuum. Actions may be taken to reduce or control the hazards concerned, such as by limiting emissions of pollutants or introducing flood control measures. The most effective long-term actions, however, are those that are preventive in approach, aimed at eliminating or reducing the forces that drive the system. | ||
range of actions. These may take many forms and be targeted at different points within the environment-health continuum. Actions may be taken to reduce or control the hazards concerned, such as by limiting emissions of pollutants or introducing flood control measures. The most effective long-term actions, however, are those that are preventive in approach, aimed at eliminating or reducing the forces that drive the system. | |||
|} | |} | ||
Latest revision as of 07:34, 6 August 2010
This page is a encyclopedia article.
The page identifier is Op_en2036 |
---|
Moderator:Alexandra Kuhn (see all) |
|
Upload data
|
<section begin=glossary />
- The INTARESE framework comprises all relevant aspects and builds on all relevant methods to provide guidance for a comprehensive integrated environmental health impact assessment.[1] It recognised the concept of the DPSIR, DPSEEA and MEME frameworks but provides a more flexible and comprehensive framework. The key attributes are:
- the full chain approach, including variables and causal relationships linking the different steps in the chain from source to impact
- the logical process of assessment (steps involved in the execution of the assessment, tasks and responsibilities of the parties involved)
- information input and models (data input and processing, applying models, transforming intermediate variables into meaningful indicators and summary indices)
- appraisal of the information from multiple perspectives
<section end=glossary />
Framework | Impact Pathway Approach | Full chain | DPSIR | DPSEEA |
---|---|---|---|---|
Used by whom | ExternE | Intarese / Heimtsa | EEA | WHO |
Source | [2] | [3] [4] | [5] [6] [7] | [8] |
Summary | The impact pathway approach allows for the determination of impacts (e.g. health effects) and damages (external costs) due to emissions of pollutants. | The full chain covers all the aspects from the other frameworks and focuses on comprehensiveness and integration. It acknowledges the importance of multi-causalities, complexity, interdependencies and uncertainty. It is limited to human health. | The causal framework for describing the interactions between society and the environment adopted by the European Environment Agency: driving forces, pressures, states, impacts, responses (extension of the PSR model developed by OECD). | The DPSEEA (Driving Forces - Pressures - State - Exposure - Effects - Actions) model is useful in designing a system of environmental health indicators within the decision-making context. |
Scenarios | Scenario development / description: comparison of (a) policy option(s) to a reference scenario | Either consider the status quo or investigate scenarios | ||
Driving forces | Activities Activities that lead to emissions, e.g. driving a car, producing energy, using hairspray |
Activities Activities that lead to emissions, e.g. driving a car, producing energy, using hairspray, natural activities like volcanoe eruptions |
Driving forces Areas in public life that exert pressure on the environment, e.g. economic sectors, households. |
Driving forces The driving forces refer to the factors that motivate and push the environmental processes involved. |
Pressures, e.g. emissions | Emissions Emissions into air, water and soil, depending on activities and emission factors; can be reduced by applying mitigation measures |
Sources: emissions, releases Due to activities and processes (natural and anthropogenic) |
Pressures Resulting environmental burden, e.g. due to waste and built-up areas |
Pressures This result is the generation of pressures on the environment. |
State of the environmental media | Concentrations / Depositions Changes in the state of the environmental media leading to impacts |
Quality of environmental media: concentration After dispersion and transformation |
State State of an environmental compartment that is exposed to the burden, e.g. changes in atmosphere and lithosphere |
State In response to the pressures, the state of the environment is often modified. |
Exposure | Concentrations / Depositions / Intake/Uptake Concentrations that effect the population intake via ingestion. Sensible area that is exposed to deposition Material that is exposed to depostion |
Exposure settings: Exposure Depending on population behaviour, e.g. time-activity pattern, product use, diet |
Exposure Deterioration in the state of the environment, however, poses risks to human well-being only when there is interplay between people and the hazards in the environment. Exposure is therefore rarely an automatic consequence of the existence of a hazard: it requires that people are present both at the place and at the time that the hazard occurs. Exposure to environmental hazards, in turn, leads to a wide spectrum of health effects, which may be acute or chronic. The concept of exposure is best developed in relation to pollutants in environmental media. The amount of the pollutant absorbed, i.e. the "dose", depends on the duration and intensity of the exposure. | |
Impacts / Effects, e.g. health effects | Impacts Impacts on the receptors, e.g. human health effects, adverse effects on crops, materials and ecosystems |
Human body: dose, health effects After inhalation, dermal exposure, ingestion Pathophysiological processes lead from a dose to a health effect |
Impacts Specific impact due to the environmental burden, e.g. greenhouse effect, soil pollution |
Effects Some hazards may have a rapid effect following exposure, whereas others may require a long time to produce an adverse health effect. |
Damages | Damages External costs of the impacts due to the emissions. Thus, the impacts are made comparable; and a cost-benefit-analysis can be conducted. |
Social, cultural, political, economical and judicial settings: Impacts Taking place of valuation and weighing; risk characterisation; e.g. policy deficits, disease burden, societal (external) costs, perceptions |
||
Answers of society / Actions | Responses Social reaction to the burden, e.g. research and laws |
Actions In face of the environmental problems and consequent health effects, society attempts to adopt and implement a range of actions. These may take many forms and be targeted at different points within the environment-health continuum. Actions may be taken to reduce or control the hazards concerned, such as by limiting emissions of pollutants or introducing flood control measures. The most effective long-term actions, however, are those that are preventive in approach, aimed at eliminating or reducing the forces that drive the system. |
References
- ↑ D5 Intarese Conceptual Model of Assessment Framework (May 2007)
- ↑ http://www.externe.info/
- ↑ http://www.intarese.org
- ↑ Briggs, D. (2008). "A framework for integrated environmental health impact assessment of systemic risks." Environmental Health 7:61. doi:10.1186/1476-069X-7-61
- ↑ http://glossary.eea.europa.eu/EEAGlossary/D/DPSIR
- ↑ http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DPSIR
- ↑ http://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/DPSIR
- ↑ http://www.euro.who.int/EHindicators/Indicators/20030527_2